You can only have it one way for the rest of your life.
You can only have it one way for the rest of your life.
by I_fuck_w_tacos
42 Comments
cyberchrono
mayo butter ftw
alematt
I’d need to taste test before deciding
melodyknows
Butter.
Economy_Fortune_5529
Olive oil and butter 💯
JustAGirl319
🧈
DaCheesemonger
Butter
MsToshaRae
Olive oil and butter yum 
juanitovaldeznuts
Straight butter. I swear you mayo folks like an oily mess.
king_ender200
Didn’t even know you could make it with anything other than butter, guess I’m not a true Grilled Cheese fan
itsalovelydayforSTFU
Kerrygold butter
CaptainPeachfuzz
Has anyone tried ghee?
BigCommieMachine
Duck Fat.
steen311
I’m a margerine guy myself
Poesoe
butter
Desperson
If you get the chance try mayo + yellow mustard. Like 5 parts mayo to 1 part mustard. Make enough to cover your bread wall to wall with enough left over to put inside the sandwich after if you’re making an egg and cheese or burger.
PurpleBear89
Oh, butter.
Anfie22
Butter
xellentboildpot8oes
Butter
greeneyes826
Smoked bacon fat
AJZong
Butter wins by a mile
FrankIsLost
Butter + primal kitchen chipotle lime mayo
Asborn-kam1sh
Cheese mayo sandwich?
0pp0site0fbatman
Butter all day.
dayzers
It was never going to be anything except butter until I saw this post
samgag94
Butter spreaded evenly on the bread
Xisle_
Mayo but it has to be kewpie. Otherwise it’s just a mess.
LordChefChristoph
Has to be bacon fat because that means I’m also eating bacon.
ozmofasho
It would have to be butter for me, or bacon fat. I could do either for life.
rodan-rodan
Hear me out… Ranch
Ordinary_Ice_1137
So…..what’s all this other shit? Butter is the only way to make grilled cheeses
iolitm
Truffle Oil
gundersonfan
Olive oil.
Easy.
baldy74
Butter w/ a light sprinkle of garlic salt. Not pictured.
Former-Technician278
butter !!! 🧈
UneditedReddited
Tallow and butter
shikodo
Butter all the way. This isn’t even a contest :p
Alex_is_Baked
Butter and in the air fryer ! It’s the only way I do my grilled cheese . Partially because Olive oil is expensive but butter tastes better anyways .
cardinaljayy
Butter. Also I’m very suspicious because I didn’t even know this was a sub but it was recommended and I just had grilled cheese 😭
dDreamIsReal
Butter is the way
paulie732
Butter
techm00
I’ll just stick with butter. best tasting, and best browing. Mayo works if I’m out of butter, but it’s not *quite* there.
BenAwesomeness3
Mayo and butter. The only way I’ve ever had it, and the only valid way
42 Comments
mayo butter ftw
I’d need to taste test before deciding
Butter.
Olive oil and butter 💯
🧈
Butter
Olive oil and butter yum 
Straight butter. I swear you mayo folks like an oily mess.
Didn’t even know you could make it with anything other than butter, guess I’m not a true Grilled Cheese fan
Kerrygold butter
Has anyone tried ghee?
Duck Fat.
I’m a margerine guy myself
butter
If you get the chance try mayo + yellow mustard. Like 5 parts mayo to 1 part mustard. Make enough to cover your bread wall to wall with enough left over to put inside the sandwich after if you’re making an egg and cheese or burger.
Oh, butter.
Butter
Butter
Smoked bacon fat
Butter wins by a mile
Butter + primal kitchen chipotle lime mayo
Cheese mayo sandwich?
Butter all day.
It was never going to be anything except butter until I saw this post
Butter spreaded evenly on the bread
Mayo but it has to be kewpie. Otherwise it’s just a mess.
Has to be bacon fat because that means I’m also eating bacon.
It would have to be butter for me, or bacon fat. I could do either for life.
Hear me out… Ranch
So…..what’s all this other shit? Butter is the only way to make grilled cheeses
Truffle Oil
Olive oil.
Easy.
Butter w/ a light sprinkle of garlic salt. Not pictured.
butter !!! 🧈
Tallow and butter
Butter all the way. This isn’t even a contest :p
Butter and in the air fryer ! It’s the only way I do my grilled cheese . Partially because Olive oil is expensive but butter tastes better anyways .
Butter. Also I’m very suspicious because I didn’t even know this was a sub but it was recommended and I just had grilled cheese 😭
Butter is the way
Butter
I’ll just stick with butter. best tasting, and best browing. Mayo works if I’m out of butter, but it’s not *quite* there.
Mayo and butter. The only way I’ve ever had it, and the only valid way